the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Linking northeastern North Pacific oxygen changes to upstream surface outcrop variations
Kyla Drushka
Abstract. Understanding the response of the ocean to global warming, including the renewal of ocean waters from the surface (ventilation), is important for future climate predictions. Oxygen (O2) distributions in the ocean thermocline have proven an effective way to infer changes in ventilation because physical processes (ventilation and circulation) that supply oxygen are thought to be primarily responsible for changes in interior oxygen concentrations. Here, the focus is on the North Pacific thermocline, where some of the world ocean's largest oxygen variations have been observed. These variations, described as bi-decadal cycles on top of a small declining trend, are strongest on subsurface isopycnals that outcrop into the mixed layer of the northwestern North Pacific in late winter. In this study, surface density time series are reconstructed in this area using observational data only and focusing on the time period from 1982, the first full year of the satellite SST record, to 2020. It is found that changes in maximum annual outcrop area of the densest isopycnals outcropping in the northwestern North Pacific are correlated with interannual oxygen variability observed at Ocean Station P (OSP) downstream at about a 10-year lag. The hypothesis is that ocean ventilation/uptake of oxygen is greatly reduced when the outcrop areas are small and that this signal travels within the North Pacific Current to OSP, with 10 years being at the higher end of transit times reported in other studies. It is also found that sea surface salinity (SSS) dominates over sea surface temperature (SST) in driving interannual fluctuations in maximum annual surface density in the northwestern North Pacific, highlighting the role that salinity may play in altering ocean ventilation. In contrast, SSS and SST contribute about equally to the long-term declining surface density trends that are superimposed on the interannual cycles.
- Preprint
(2839 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Sabine Mecking and Kyla Drushka
Status: open (until 18 Oct 2023)
-
RC1: 'Comment on bg-2023-132', Anonymous Referee #1, 15 Sep 2023
reply
This study attempts to understand the causes of decadal variability of dissolved oxygen in the Gulf of Alaska, observed at the Ocean Station P (OSP) at 145°W, 50°N. The oxygen timeseries at the OSP is the longest record of dissolved oxygen. The decadal variability of this data has been studied intensely over the last 20+ years and there are many hypotheses proposed to explain this variability. This study put forward the idea that the subduction of thermocline waters generates oxygen variability in the western Pacific, which would then propagate eastward following the circulation pathway of the North Pacific Current. Approximately 10 years later, the signal reaches the OSP and is observed there.
This hypothesis itself is not new, but what is new in this study is that a significant correlation was found between dissolved oxygen at OSP and the isopycnal outcrop area in the western Pacific which was reconstructed from the historical observations (EN4). Furthermore, the outcrop area is controlled by the density of the sea water at the surface, which further depends on the variability of sea surface salinity, rather than temperature. However, this variability does not exhibit significant correlation with the dominant mode of climate variability in this region. The maximum lag-correlation values are on the order of 0.5 to 0.6, which would explain about 25-36% of the total variance. This seems a significant contribution to the total oxygen variability, while it also leaves significant room for other mechanisms as well. My overall impression is that the manuscript contains significant progress on this problem and merits publication. Having said this, I would like to raise two points that the authors can consider for a revision.Â
At L75, the authors choose to analyze data after 1982 only. I ask the authors to reconsider this choice because dissolved oxygen data from OSP exists from 1956. Since the focus of this study is the decadal variability with approximately 20-year timescale, the statistical significance of this analysis is critically limited by the effective sample size. The additional 26 years of data can capture additional full cycle of the signal potentially. Figure 2 indeed supports that the EN4-derived outcrop areas show the same pattern of maxima and minima as EN4-OISST. Then, it is possible to include the additional, extended timeseries before 1982.
At L135, it does make qualitative sense that a larger outcrop area indicates more ventilation, and a smaller outcrop area indicates less ventilation. However, not enough reasons were provided to justify why the spatial extent of the surface outcrop area is used as the only proxy for the amount of ventilation. There are atmospheric reanalysis data products available for estimating buoyancy and wind stress forcing. The latter can provide an estimate of Ekman flow. Mixed layer depths and geostrophic circulation can also be estimated from EN4 products. It makes me wonder if there were any reason that direct subduction estimates weren’t used in this study. It is possible that these calculations were already performed by the authors or prior studies by others. If this is the case, it would be important to include this information.
Â
Â
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-2023-132-RC1
Sabine Mecking and Kyla Drushka
Sabine Mecking and Kyla Drushka
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
170 | 42 | 9 | 221 | 4 | 3 |
- HTML: 170
- PDF: 42
- XML: 9
- Total: 221
- BibTeX: 4
- EndNote: 3
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1