No change in topsoil carbon levels of Great Britain, 1978–2007

Abstract. Soil is an important store of carbon (C) and there has been recent concern that accelerated loss of carbon from the soil may be reinforcing climate change. There is therefore a need to both track current trends in soil C storage and to identify how soil can contribute to carbon emission reduction targets. Countryside Survey (CS) is an integrated national monitoring program in which vegetation, topsoil, water and land use measurements are made across Great Britain (GB). The soil component of CS is unique as topsoil C concentrations have been measured at three time points (1978, 1998 and 2007) together with topsoil bulk density (2007 only), vegetation composition (all years), and land use (i.e. Broad Habitat, 1998, 2007). The combined dataset allows estimates of change in topsoil C stock over time and the influence of land use change on topsoil C to be investigated. Results indicate that although there was a small increase (8%) in topsoil C concentration between 1978 and 1998 and small decrease (6.5%) between 1998 and 2007, there was no significant change in GB topsoil C concentration (in g kg⁻¹), density (in t ha⁻¹) or stock (in Tg) between 1978 and 2007. Within individual habitats some consistent trends were observed and by examining plots which had consistent vegetation composition since 1978 we demonstrate that land use change was not responsible for the few significant changes that were found. These results are comparable with the few other estimates of recent topsoil C concentration and stock changes in W. Europe, with the exception of a previous study in England and Wales which reported significant topsoil C losses of up to 50% over a similar period. Possible reasons for the contradictory findings are discussed. An extra 220–730 Tg of C would be stored in topsoil C stocks if all GB soils were optimised at the top 5–25% C densities as recorded for each habitat in 2007.