K. Fenn , Y. Malhi , M. Morecroft , C. Lloyd , and M. Thomas
There exist very few comprehensive descriptions of the productivity and carbon cycling of forest ecosystems. Here we present a description of the components of annual Net Primary Productivity (NPP), Gross Primary Productivity (GPP), autotrophic and heterotrophic respiration, and ecosystem respiration (R ECO ) for a temperate mixed deciduous woodland at Wytham Woods in southern Britain, calculated using "bottom-up" biometric and chamber measurements (leaf and wood production and soil and stem respiration). These are compared with estimates of these parameters from eddy-covariance measurements made at the same site. NPP was estimated as 7.0±0.8 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 , and GPP as 20.3+1.0 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 , a value which closely matched to eddy covariance-derived GPP value of 21.1 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 . Annual R ECO was calculated as 18.9±1.7 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 , close to the eddy covariance value of 19.8 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 ; the seasonal cycle of biometric and eddy covariance R ECO estimates also closely matched. The consistency between eddy covariance and biometric measurements substantially strengthens the confidence we attach to each as alternative indicators of site carbon dynamics, and permits an integrated perspective of the ecosystem carbon cycle. 37% of NPP was allocated below ground, and the ecosystem carbon use efficiency (CUE, = NPP/GPP) calculated to be 0.35±0.05, lower than reported for many temperate broadleaved sites.
Received: 25 Mar 2010 – Discussion started: 21 May 2010
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
K. Fenn , Y. Malhi , M. Morecroft , C. Lloyd , and M. Thomas
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
K. Fenn , Y. Malhi , M. Morecroft , C. Lloyd , and M. Thomas
K. Fenn , Y. Malhi , M. Morecroft , C. Lloyd , and M. Thomas
Viewed
Total article views: 2,167 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,085
948
134
2,167
74
67
HTML: 1,085
PDF: 948
XML: 134
Total: 2,167
BibTeX: 74
EndNote: 67
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
19
17
5
41
Mar 2013
8
13
1
22
Apr 2013
7
19
1
27
May 2013
9
36
0
45
Jun 2013
10
21
0
31
Jul 2013
5
10
0
15
Aug 2013
1
3
0
4
Sep 2013
5
24
4
33
Oct 2013
6
31
2
39
Nov 2013
6
11
5
22
Dec 2013
2
13
6
21
Jan 2014
8
11
3
22
Feb 2014
7
14
3
24
Mar 2014
9
35
3
47
Apr 2014
9
35
4
48
May 2014
5
31
7
43
Jun 2014
9
13
7
29
Jul 2014
4
12
2
18
Aug 2014
5
16
0
21
Sep 2014
4
27
0
31
Oct 2014
10
30
0
40
Nov 2014
13
22
1
36
Dec 2014
21
34
2
57
Jan 2015
4
4
0
8
Feb 2015
10
1
1
12
Mar 2015
10
2
0
12
Apr 2015
13
3
0
16
May 2015
6
4
1
11
Jun 2015
5
4
1
10
Jul 2015
8
1
0
9
Aug 2015
5
2
1
8
Sep 2015
1
7
0
8
Oct 2015
12
14
1
27
Nov 2015
12
12
0
24
Dec 2015
5
0
5
Jan 2016
15
10
2
27
Feb 2016
6
8
0
14
Mar 2016
7
5
0
12
Apr 2016
6
3
0
9
May 2016
8
7
0
15
Jun 2016
4
0
4
Jul 2016
4
2
2
8
Aug 2016
6
2
0
8
Sep 2016
7
0
7
Oct 2016
3
4
0
7
Nov 2016
5
4
0
9
Dec 2016
6
2
1
9
Jan 2017
5
2
0
7
Feb 2017
10
2
0
12
Mar 2017
21
4
2
27
Apr 2017
20
12
1
33
May 2017
24
3
1
28
Jun 2017
23
2
1
26
Jul 2017
8
2
0
10
Aug 2017
3
3
0
6
Sep 2017
3
7
0
10
Oct 2017
3
5
0
8
Nov 2017
7
5
0
12
Dec 2017
4
6
0
10
Jan 2018
4
6
0
10
Feb 2018
13
4
1
18
Mar 2018
9
5
1
15
Apr 2018
6
5
0
11
May 2018
6
7
0
13
Jun 2018
4
6
0
10
Jul 2018
7
5
0
12
Aug 2018
4
8
1
13
Sep 2018
8
15
0
23
Oct 2018
8
10
0
18
Nov 2018
6
11
0
17
Dec 2018
9
9
0
18
Jan 2019
9
3
0
12
Feb 2019
4
4
1
9
Mar 2019
6
7
0
13
Apr 2019
7
1
0
8
May 2019
3
1
0
4
Jun 2019
5
8
0
13
Jul 2019
2
2
0
4
Aug 2019
4
2
0
6
Sep 2019
8
6
0
14
Oct 2019
5
2
0
7
Nov 2019
5
0
5
Dec 2019
2
4
0
6
Jan 2020
1
4
0
5
Feb 2020
9
12
1
22
Mar 2020
6
8
0
14
Apr 2020
10
3
3
16
May 2020
1
0
1
Jun 2020
11
3
0
14
Jul 2020
16
3
2
21
Aug 2020
3
4
4
11
Sep 2020
2
0
2
Oct 2020
8
7
1
16
Nov 2020
12
10
1
23
Dec 2020
15
2
2
19
Jan 2021
4
7
0
11
Feb 2021
10
2
0
12
Mar 2021
15
4
0
19
Apr 2021
11
4
0
15
May 2021
6
1
1
8
Jun 2021
3
3
6
Jul 2021
2
0
2
Aug 2021
10
3
0
13
Sep 2021
2
1
0
3
Oct 2021
9
4
0
13
Nov 2021
8
3
1
12
Dec 2021
9
6
2
17
Jan 2022
8
2
0
10
Feb 2022
8
5
1
14
Mar 2022
9
5
2
16
Apr 2022
11
6
1
18
May 2022
11
5
0
16
Jun 2022
9
2
1
12
Jul 2022
4
0
4
Aug 2022
8
1
9
Sep 2022
11
6
0
17
Oct 2022
2
2
4
Nov 2022
10
3
0
13
Dec 2022
8
2
2
12
Jan 2023
11
2
2
15
Feb 2023
5
4
1
10
Mar 2023
9
3
0
12
Apr 2023
5
2
0
7
May 2023
11
3
0
14
Jun 2023
4
2
2
8
Jul 2023
7
0
7
Aug 2023
8
2
1
11
Sep 2023
17
2
1
20
Oct 2023
6
1
2
9
Nov 2023
5
0
5
Dec 2023
3
3
4
10
Jan 2024
6
2
1
9
Feb 2024
13
3
0
16
Mar 2024
17
5
2
24
Apr 2024
9
4
2
15
May 2024
16
3
5
24
Jun 2024
4
1
5
Jul 2024
8
3
11
Aug 2024
9
0
9
Sep 2024
8
3
0
11
Oct 2024
1
1
0
2
Nov 2024
3
3
1
7
Dec 2024
3
0
3
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
19
17
5
Mar 2013
27
30
6
Apr 2013
34
49
7
May 2013
43
85
7
Jun 2013
53
106
7
Jul 2013
58
116
7
Aug 2013
59
119
7
Sep 2013
64
143
11
Oct 2013
70
174
13
Nov 2013
76
185
18
Dec 2013
78
198
24
Jan 2014
86
209
27
Feb 2014
93
223
30
Mar 2014
102
258
33
Apr 2014
111
293
37
May 2014
116
324
44
Jun 2014
125
337
51
Jul 2014
129
349
53
Aug 2014
134
365
53
Sep 2014
138
392
53
Oct 2014
148
422
53
Nov 2014
161
444
54
Dec 2014
182
478
56
Jan 2015
186
482
56
Feb 2015
196
483
57
Mar 2015
206
485
57
Apr 2015
219
488
57
May 2015
225
492
58
Jun 2015
230
496
59
Jul 2015
238
497
59
Aug 2015
243
499
60
Sep 2015
244
506
60
Oct 2015
256
520
61
Nov 2015
268
532
61
Dec 2015
268
537
61
Jan 2016
283
547
63
Feb 2016
289
555
63
Mar 2016
296
560
63
Apr 2016
302
563
63
May 2016
310
570
63
Jun 2016
314
570
63
Jul 2016
318
572
65
Aug 2016
324
574
65
Sep 2016
331
574
65
Oct 2016
334
578
65
Nov 2016
339
582
65
Dec 2016
345
584
66
Jan 2017
350
586
66
Feb 2017
360
588
66
Mar 2017
381
592
68
Apr 2017
401
604
69
May 2017
425
607
70
Jun 2017
448
609
71
Jul 2017
456
611
71
Aug 2017
459
614
71
Sep 2017
462
621
71
Oct 2017
465
626
71
Nov 2017
472
631
71
Dec 2017
476
637
71
Jan 2018
480
643
71
Feb 2018
493
647
72
Mar 2018
502
652
73
Apr 2018
508
657
73
May 2018
514
664
73
Jun 2018
518
670
73
Jul 2018
525
675
73
Aug 2018
529
683
74
Sep 2018
537
698
74
Oct 2018
545
708
74
Nov 2018
551
719
74
Dec 2018
560
728
74
Jan 2019
569
731
74
Feb 2019
573
735
75
Mar 2019
579
742
75
Apr 2019
586
743
75
May 2019
589
744
75
Jun 2019
594
752
75
Jul 2019
596
754
75
Aug 2019
600
756
75
Sep 2019
608
762
75
Oct 2019
613
764
75
Nov 2019
613
769
75
Dec 2019
615
773
75
Jan 2020
616
777
75
Feb 2020
625
789
76
Mar 2020
631
797
76
Apr 2020
641
800
79
May 2020
642
800
79
Jun 2020
653
803
79
Jul 2020
669
806
81
Aug 2020
672
810
85
Sep 2020
674
810
85
Oct 2020
682
817
86
Nov 2020
694
827
87
Dec 2020
709
829
89
Jan 2021
713
836
89
Feb 2021
723
838
89
Mar 2021
738
842
89
Apr 2021
749
846
89
May 2021
755
847
90
Jun 2021
758
847
93
Jul 2021
760
847
93
Aug 2021
770
850
93
Sep 2021
772
851
93
Oct 2021
781
855
93
Nov 2021
789
858
94
Dec 2021
798
864
96
Jan 2022
806
866
96
Feb 2022
814
871
97
Mar 2022
823
876
99
Apr 2022
834
882
100
May 2022
845
887
100
Jun 2022
854
889
101
Jul 2022
858
889
101
Aug 2022
866
889
102
Sep 2022
877
895
102
Oct 2022
879
895
104
Nov 2022
889
898
104
Dec 2022
897
900
106
Jan 2023
908
902
108
Feb 2023
913
906
109
Mar 2023
922
909
109
Apr 2023
927
911
109
May 2023
938
914
109
Jun 2023
942
916
111
Jul 2023
949
916
111
Aug 2023
957
918
112
Sep 2023
974
920
113
Oct 2023
980
921
115
Nov 2023
985
921
115
Dec 2023
988
924
119
Jan 2024
994
926
120
Feb 2024
1,007
929
120
Mar 2024
1,024
934
122
Apr 2024
1,033
938
124
May 2024
1,049
941
129
Jun 2024
1,053
941
130
Jul 2024
1,061
941
133
Aug 2024
1,070
941
133
Sep 2024
1,078
944
133
Oct 2024
1,079
945
133
Nov 2024
1,082
948
134
Dec 2024
1,085
948
134
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 13 Dec 2024