Articles | Volume 22, issue 9
https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-22-2225-2025
© Author(s) 2025. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Ecosystem leaf area, gross primary production, and evapotranspiration responses to wildfire in the Columbia River basin
Download
- Final revised paper (published on 09 May 2025)
- Supplement to the final revised paper
- Preprint (discussion started on 26 Jul 2024)
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor
| : Report abuse
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2024-2217', Tempest McCabe, 04 Sep 2024
- AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Mingjie Shi, 12 Nov 2024
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2024-2217', Anonymous Referee #2, 19 Sep 2024
- AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Mingjie Shi, 12 Nov 2024
Peer review completion
AR – Author's response | RR – Referee report | ED – Editor decision | EF – Editorial file upload
ED: Reconsider after major revisions (20 Nov 2024) by Andrew Feldman
AR by Mingjie Shi on behalf of the Authors (24 Nov 2024)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Reconsider after major revisions (26 Nov 2024) by Andrew Feldman
ED: Referee Nomination & Report Request started (27 Nov 2024) by Andrew Feldman
RR by Tempest McCabe (17 Dec 2024)
RR by Anonymous Referee #2 (21 Dec 2024)
ED: Publish subject to minor revisions (review by editor) (06 Jan 2025) by Andrew Feldman
AR by Mingjie Shi on behalf of the Authors (21 Jan 2025)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Publish as is (29 Jan 2025) by Andrew Feldman
AR by Mingjie Shi on behalf of the Authors (05 Feb 2025)
Manuscript
General comments:
The paper “Ecosystem leaf area, gross primary production, and Evapotranspiration Responses to Wildfire in the Columbia River Basin” examines how different vegetation types recovered after a severe fire season during 2015, looking at MODIS LAI, GPP and ET products combined with the MBTS burn serenity classification data. The authors targeted concepts of “resistance” and “resilience” by looking at the difference in LAI, GPP, and ET in years following 2015 compared to the interannual variability of years prior to 2015. The authors then use a random forest feature importance to determine if vapor pressure deficit, precipitation, or burn severity were most important in determining how resilient a vegetation type was. They found that grasses were more resistant and resilient than savannahs and needleleaf evergreen forests, and that LAI was more responsive to burn severity than GPP and ET.
I found this paper to address important scientific concepts. The authors’ application of concepts of resilience and resistance was an important and interesting lens to explore how disturbances affect landscapes. I also found the paper to have some major flaws, specifically pertaining to how the authors document uncertainty within their analyses, and the independence of the MODIS LAI, GPP, and ET products. I identified minor flaws in some elements of how the analysis was scoped and discussed.
Notably, the materials I received for review had no supplemental materials, but the paper makes reference in the text to several supplemental elements. The text will need to be edited substantially if the supplement was intentionally excluded.
Major comments:
This paper lacks discussion of uncertainty in interpreting the results presented. For example, in Figure 2 the only delineation of uncertainty is that of interannual variability. It’s unclear if that interannual variability is mean to be interpreted as the threshold for “significant difference”, and if that is the case it is in contradiction with some of the writing (see comments for line 355). A single number to describe a year gave me pause as a reviewer. Similarly, Figures 3 and figures 4 present single-point comparative data with nothing to contextualize the uncertainty around that single point. This is particularly relevant for figures 3 and 4, because the range in inter-annual resistance and resilience presented in figure 4 is sometimes larger than the differences in resistance and resilience between different vegetation-types. Interpreting if the differences presented are meaningful is left to the reader, undercutting interesting patterns. In the text, discussion of uncertainty only acknowledges limitations of remotely-sensed LAI, and does not discuss the specific uncertainties and limitations unique to the paper itself. While more appropriate to the methods section, the text also does not discuss spatial uncertainty.
Second, it is unclear if the MODIS LAI, GPP, and ET are independent enough to draw separate conclusions. The authors wisely acknowledge in line 384 that the MODIS GPP and ET products use MODIS LAI as an input, along with meteorological data. However, this does call into question if the finding that LAI responds more to burn severity than GPP or ET, because GPP and ET definitionally contain the same information as the LAI product, plus other variables that don’t respond to burn severity. If the GPP and ET product contain information that could respond to burn severity beyond LAI, then that needs to be explicitly stated.
Minor comments:
Methods: Grasses could grow back faster than the “resilience”/ “resistance” increment of 1 year. Is it appropriate to consider grasses’ “resistance” in the first year post fire?
Line 85- Citation how LAI related to prediction uncertainties of earth system models?
Line 160-164 – This seems to contradict methods described in lines 193-195
Line 186 - Difficulty understanding the sentence beginning with “Specifically…” What information is applied? Is this referring to MODIS pixels that span multiple fires, or each fire-MODIS pair?
Line 195 - Table 1 seems more appropriate to a supplement. Perhaps a column indicating the years used in this study?
Line 245 - 248: Citation/ discussion for why 100 trained models were sufficient.
Lines 250-258: This paragraph reads as more relevant to the methods section, and the writing shifts from present tense to past tense.
Figure 1 - Also seems more appropriate for a supplement. More discussion/ visual delineation of uncertainty would make this a more powerful figure. For example, why not include error bars for the years themselves? Finally, while the text claims climate variations in years (is that distinct from interanual variability?) are not confounding, 2019 seems to be different than other years compared to the interannual variability of 2001-2014 in precipitation. This is not discussed, and specifically how years are not significantly different is not defined.
Line 355 - Seems to contradict Figure 2 – 2019 is higher than 2020 in GPP. Also, if “Recover” is defined as reaching the same value within the variability of 2011-2014, then many metrics did not “recover” at all.
Line 321-322 Cite statement about overfitting.
443 - The connection between this research and afforestation and sustainable agriculture is unclear in this current writing.
Conclusions: Potential uses for this research for the calibration of ESM is discussed for the first time in the conclusions.
Technical Corrections:
Line 209: - Additional period.
Line 278: “S” denoting severity and “S” denoting supplement both is confusing.
Line 316 important scores -> importance scores
364 - fully - full
395- interacting -> interaction
425 “findings that obtained with” -> findings from, “potential of” -> “potential for”
428 - unclear what is meant by “reasonable data quality controls”